CHIP MINEMYER | McCain should have spoken from afar » Columns

Columns

Related Photos

Chip Minemyer Tribune-Democrat File Photo

Discussion

September 11, 2008

CHIP MINEMYER | McCain should have spoken from afar

Anonymous The Tribune-Democrat Thu Sep 11, 2008, 10:15 PM EDT

John McCain said the right things Thursday at Shanksville.

But he shouldn’t have been there at all.

The Arizona senator paid tribute to the 40 victims of Flight 93, which crashed in a field here on Sept. 11, 2001. He spoke eloquently of their courage and sacrifice.

And by no means did this memorial service degenerate into a campaign rally. Tact was applied, and the candidate was appropriately somber. Still, the ceremony to mark the seventh anniversary of the terrorist attacks was not the place for someone running for president.

Shanksville on this day was not the place for campaign buttons that dotted the crowd of more than 400. It was not the place for the “Go John!” calls from the crowd that greeted the candidate when he arrived, or the cheers that arose when he visited with well-wishers and when he approached the lectern to speak. The Flight 93 crash site is not the place for politics.

McCain was joined at the ceremony by his wife, Cindy. Both the Republican candidate and Barack Obama, his Democratic rival, were to appear later at ground zero in New York. Each pledged to set aside the political rhetoric for the day.

But they should have made the better choice – both of them – and simply stayed away.

The crowd at Shanksville swelled to twice the size of last year’s gathering. People lifted digital cameras and cell phones, trying to capture an image of the presidential hopeful.

An Iraq war veteran in the crowd spoke passionately about his service and the sacrifice of the Flight 93 passengers and crew. But he also produced a business card bearing the Republican Party logo and declared himself a McCain supporter. This was not the time for that statement.

The Flight 93 crash site is a place for quiet reflection. It is a place for sorrow over the tragedy that occurred there and a place to be uplifted at the thought of ordinary people making the ultimate sacrifice in a moment of unimaginable horror.

Those working toward a permanent memorial at Shanksville have an ally in McCain. He has donated money to the effort. He has promised to push for completion of the project.

Indeed, this candidate is a decorated war hero, a former prisoner of war. If anyone can speak of sacrifice for one’s country, of facing life-threatening circumstances and choosing the right path regardless, it is John McCain.

But on this day, he should have offered his tribute from afar.

Chip Minemyer is the editor of The Tribune-Democrat. He can be reached at 532-5091.

Text Only | Photo Reprints

Columns

CORY ISENBERG | Postseason action heating up
With conference track and field championships decided, district championships in 5 and
6 are set for this week.
On Tuesday, the District 6-AA meet is scheduled for Altoona’s Mansion Park while the District 5 Class AA meet will be held on Wednesday at Northern Bedford County High School.

May 13, 2012 1 Photo
CORY ISENBERG| A long night at Mansion Park
The final 1600 relay races had run, trophies had been awarded and the stands were nearly empty except for a few remaining reporters Friday night at Altoona’s Mansion Park.
The 63rd annual West-Central Coaches Track and Field Invitational was complete for the most part except for one last event.

May 6, 2012 1 Photo
CORY ISENBERG| Area competitors do well at Shippensburg
The 86th annual Jack Roddick Shippensburg University High School Track and Field Invitational was held on Saturday and several area participants had quality performances at the event.
In Class AA, Forest Hills senior Sam Deitle won the high jump competition with a leap of 5 feet while Bedford senior Carrie Baker was third in the pole vault (10-6) and sixth in the 800.
Bisons’ teammate Kaitlyn Lippencott was fifth in the triple jump and Bedford’s 400 relay and 1600 relay were both eighth.

April 22, 2012 1 Photo
BILL EGGERT | Teen idol guided us through music revolution
He first hit the national spotlight as host of a popular teen dance show. Later this ambitious workaholic branched out and added game shows, award shows and syndicated radio shows to his media empire – becoming a true media mogul.

April 22, 2012 1 Photo
GORDON TOMB | Obama a threat to low-cost gas
If it is possible to kill the layer of the golden egg that is low natural gas prices, you can count on the Obama administration to find a way.

April 19, 2012 1 Photo
STEPHEN VEROTSKY | Conservatives _ a label not easily defined
Candidates running for national office who claim to be conservatives need to be more specific.

April 14, 2012 1 Photo
COMMISSIONERS CORNER | Board reflects on achievements of first 100 days
Can you believe we have almost bridged the 100-day point in office?
It’s time to reflect on what has been accomplished, not by us alone, but through the hard work and dedication of those in county government.

April 3, 2012
CORY ISENBERG| First-round games had their drama
Six teams from the area advanced to the Round of 16, the sweet 16 if you will, in the PIAA basketball playoffs.
The first round featured some dramatic moments for many teams over the weekend, but especially for the Shade boys and the Conemaugh Valley girls.

March 12, 2012 1 Photo
Ailing coach leads UConn past Pitt
Jim Calhoun was advised not to return to the bench so soon after back surgery, and was supposed to take it easy if he did.
So much for following doctor’s orders.

March 4, 2012 1 Photo
MIKE MASTOVICH | An eventful season for Callihans
The three Callihan brothers have gone through more cellphone minutes than usual during the current District 6 basketball playoff run.

March 3, 2012 1 Photo
More Columns Headlines

Columns

Search Results

Related Photos

Discussion

CHIP MINEMYER | McCain should have spoken from afar

Should the speed limit on sections of the Pennsylvania Turnpike and related highways be raised to 70 mph from 65 mph.

Contact Us