Crunch time in 12th district

Editorials

Discussion

October 3, 2006

Irey, Murtha need to debate the issues

Anonymous The Tribune-Democrat Tue Oct 03, 2006, 03:01 PM EDT

It is time for a debate in the 12th Congressional District race.

Voters deserve more than the constant Iraq-war rhetoric they have been getting from incumbent John Murtha and the steady attacks on Murtha’s character from challenger Diana Irey.

While this race has not lacked for drama, it has lacked for substance.

Irey has called three press conferences in the past week – each time reacting to published information about Murtha.

n First, she responded to stories about Murtha’s fundraising efforts by calling for an investigation of the congressman’s tactics.

n Then, she called for Murtha to respond to a newly released video tied to his involvement in the Abscam scandal in the late 1970s and early 1980s.

n Finally, she reacted Tuesday to a weekend New York Times article that described Murtha’s penchant for wheeling and dealing in the House, and his willingness to partner with representatives of both parties – none of which was news to people who know Murtha.

For Murtha’s part, he has hardly recognized that there is a race. He has spent much more time defending his Iraq war statements and helping other Democrats raise campaign money than actually talking about the issues in his home district.

Even a Saturday rally in Johnstown’s Central Park was all about Murtha’s support for the military in the face of criticism from “Veterans for the Truth” and other organizations, without acknowledging that the stated mission of the “Boot Murtha” effort is to keep the longtime congressman from getting re-elected.

It all makes for interesting theater. But voters deserve more.

Let’s get these candidates together to talk about the issues:

n Immigration and national security;

n Government spending;

n Fuel costs and dependence upon foreign oil;

n Health care;

n Abortion and family values.

These are all topics Irey has said are important to her. They are among the platforms for her campaign highlighted on her Web site – www.irey.com.

Let’s talk about them.

Murtha likes to point to the number of jobs he’s brought to the district, to his ability to steer defense contracts back to his home region. He likes to tout his impact on health care in the region. (His Web site: www.house.gov/murtha/)

Let’s talk about that, too.

The Tribune-Democrat has offered to help schedule and sponsor a congressional debate. Local electronic media have made similar offers.

Voters deserve a chance to see these candidates debate the issues face to face.

Text Only | Photo Reprints

Editorials

Readers' Forum 5-27 | Fundraiser participants 'rock'
We want to thank all who helped with and participated in the seventh annual “Cruisin for Courtney” fundraiser on May 20 in honor of Courtney Lynn Rummell, who, at the tender age of 15, lost her battle with an anaplastic astrocytoma.

May 27, 2012
Be ever vigilant against thieves | Brazena copper crooks target churches
Thieves have added insult to injury for former parishioners of two closed Cambria City churches and for those volunteers working hard to preserve these two gems.

May 27, 2012
Laurels and barbs
Laurel: Hats off to federal, state and local law-enforcement agencies for busting last week what has been termed a large-scale drug trafficking ring that operated in Cambria, Indiana and Westmoreland counties.

May 26, 2012
Readers' Forum 5-26 | Kudos to sci-fi organizers for fresh thinking
I was lifted by the story “Sci-fi buffs gather in Ebensburg” in the Sunday edition of The Tribune-Democrat.

May 26, 2012
Joe Gandelman | Are hoodies 'thug gear'?
If someone shoots a person wearing a hoodie, could it be partially explained because it made the person look like a menacing gangster? Apparently that continues to be the view of Fox News’ fading, mustachioed news personality Geraldo Rivera, who is at it again.

May 26, 2012
Hospitals’ finances are on the mend | State report a reason for optimism
While the champagne isn’t being uncorked at area hospitals, financial reports for the past fiscal year aren’t doom and gloom, either.

May 25, 2012
Needling the defiant
Students noncompliant with new state vaccination rules should not be sitting in a classroom this morning.

May 25, 2012
George Hancock | A changing landscape – not always for good
Change is constant in a runner’s life. The weather can change in mere moments, creating numerous challenges.

May 25, 2012 1 Photo
Readers' Forum 5-25 | Oppose rink relocation; alliance responds
If you think finding a parking space at or near Roxbury Park is difficult now, prepare to be extremely frustrated.

May 25, 2012
Readers' Forum 5-25 | Area matchless in heritage of service
The Armed Forces dinner, held recently at Pitt-Johnstown, was truly a night to remember for the 200 people who attended.

May 24, 2012
More Editorials Headlines

Editorials

Search Results

Discussion

Crunch time in 12th district

Irey, Murtha need to debate the issues

Should the speed limit on sections of the Pennsylvania Turnpike and related highways be raised to 70 mph from 65 mph.

Contact Us