EBENSBURG — A Richland Township couple may have run out of options in retrieving a puppy they say was mistakenly placed for adoption through the Humane Society of Cambria County.
On Tuesday, Judge Timothy Creany refused to order the Humane Society to release the name and address of the golden retriever’s new owners to Dr. Trevor and Judy Yardley.
They wanted to contact the new owners to see whether they would return the 4-month-old puppy, named “Casey,” to them.
Judy Yardley, who learned of the judge’s ruling from The Tribune-Democrat, became emotional as she described her love and attachment to the pup.
“It’s a terrible mistake I made, and one I have to pay dearly for ... a terrible mistake. And I will have to live with it,” she said.
Creany, in his two-page ruling, said the Humane Society, as a private, nonprofit, tax-exempt organization, is not subject to the state’s Sunshine laws or the Right to Know Act that potentially would give the public access to their adoption records.
“A change of heart” about the puppy is not legal grounds to throw out the adoption form Judy Yardley signed, the judge said.
Judy Yardley indicated that the couple, who represented themselves, are unlikely to appeal the decision. A ruling on the case by an appellate court could affect pet adoptions across Pennsylvania.
The Humane Society argued that forcing the release of the names could have a chilling effect on adoptions.
“I think we’ve done everything we can,” Judy Yardley said. “I believe the people who have her (puppy) should come forward and give her back.”
She took the dog – one of two owned by the Yardleys – to the pound March 20 because, she told the society, “Husband doesn’t want (it).”
Within hours, she returned to the shelter to get the dog back, only to be told it already had been adopted.
D Black, the society’s director, previously said that the new owners were not interested in giving the pup back and did not want to be identified.
Neither Black nor Michael Stibich, the Humane Society’s attorney, could be reached for comment.
Elsewhere in his ruling, Creany said Judy Yardley had the legal authority to bind both herself and her husband to her action.
It was unfortunate, Creany said, that Trevor Yardley did not convey to his wife that he had reconsidered his directive to her to get rid of the dog.
Creany, a dog owner himself, was sympathetic to Judy Yardley but indicated that was not sufficient for him to rule in the couple’s favor.
“We understand Mrs. Yardley’s testimony that she was frustrated and upset and did not properly read the contract that she signed at the agency, and that she may have had a misunderstanding as to what the agreement was,” the judge said.
“But a court may not reform nor nullify a contract on these grounds – essentially, a change of heart – however supportive the facts might be.”
Local News
Couple lose their puppy plea
- Local News
-
-
Somerset County teacher accused of using insulting names
School board members and administrators say they’re still investigating whether a teacher called her eighth- and ninth-grade algebra students names like “retard,” “idiot” and “moron.”
-
Seward tax preparer set to plead in federal court
A Westmoreland County tax preparer is scheduled to plead guilty or no contest to charges that he filed fraudulent income tax returns for his customers and asked some of them to lie to Internal Revenue Service investigators.
-
Police probing financial irregularities at Indiana County parish
State police say they’re investigating financial “irregularities” at a Catholic parish with five worship sites in Indiana County, after the local diocese reported the problems to police.
-
Blogging with heart
Anyone else have this issue: The more I know the more I want to learn.
As I am writing my heart month stories for this week’s packages, I occasionally come across a term or description unfamiliar to me. So I look it up. And then the definition or article has something else that sounds important, so I look that up. -
Video: Young bear, wolf play together
It’s like something out of a children's book: A bear cub meets a wolf cub and they become the best of friends. Even though they are different species and ferocious predators, the unlikely couple stays pals for life.
-
Two Cambria district judge offices to be cut
Two of Cambria County’s 10 magisterial districts could be eliminated as President Judge Timothy Creany looks at realigning boundaries to cut costs while taking into consideration caseloads of the district judges and population changes.
-
Westmont couple inseparable, even in death
People who knew James and Marjorie Landis of Westmont said the two were nearly always together.
-
Company buys valuables from people ready to unload
Jan Hagerich’s buffalo nickel was “healthy” – which was unhealthy for her finances.
-
Special Olympics return to region
More than 300 athletes eager to show off their skills, along with 135 coaches, will be coming to the region to take part in the 2012 Special Olympics Pennsylvania Winter Games.
-
Special Olympics Schedule
Here is a list of events related to the Pennsylvania Special Olympics Winter Games through Tuesday at venues across the region:
Saturday
• Laurel Highlands Polar Plunge to benefit Special Olympics; Quemahoning Reservoir near Boswell; registration at 9:30 a.m.; plunge at 1 p.m. - More Local News Headlines
-
Somerset County teacher accused of using insulting names
Raw Video: Italy's Mount Etna Bursts Into Life
Greeks March; Angry Despite Debt Deal
Raw Video: U.S. Pullout Celebration
Raw Video: Annual Empire State Building Run-Up
Man Killed in Courthouse Shootout
Video of Ga. Man Who Killed Girl Released
Air Force Airlines: Leaders Get Polished Service
Ga Girl Fights Off Kidnapper at Walmart
Nevada Highway Patrol, City Settle Beating Case
Homs Bombardment Continues, Global Outcry Grows
Raw Video: Dog Rescued From Icy Colo. Water
Skip the Coffee Cup and Inhale Your Caffeine Fix
