EBENSBURG — In a split 2-1 decision, Cambria County judges have dismissed a civil lawsuit against Penelec in a 2005 Hastings house fire that claimed the lives of four people.
Judges Norman Krumenacker and David Tulowitzki ruled that the utility company – which had cut off service to the house less than a week before the fire – cannot be held liable. Dissenting was Judge Timothy Creany, who said that the issue should go to a jury.
The ruling, filed late Wednesday afternoon, also dismisses liability claims against Outsourcing Solutions Inc., which made calls to utility customers about delinquent bills.
The decision grants the motions by Penelec and Outsourcing for what is known as summary judgment a week before the case was to go to trial.
Unresolved as of Thursday is whether the trial will proceed against two men who were added as defendants by Penelec. They are David Gunther, the owner of the rental property, and John Sexton, who was living in the house with his fiance and other members of her family.
It’s alleged that Gunther has liability for failing to have smoke detectors, sprinklers or fire extinguishers in the house. Sexton allegedly was negligent for lighting a tapered candle and letting it burn as a night light in the bathroom.
Authorities have said that the deadly fire was accidental, started by the unattended, burning candle on a shelf near towels and toilet paper.
Pittsburgh attorney John Bacharach, who along with attorney George Bills represents the victims, said Thursday that an appeal will be filed with the state Commonwealth Court.
“We’re disappointed obviously. We respect the judges’ opinion, but we disagree,” he said.
Bacharach said he could not say whether the trial will proceed in the meantime with Gunther and Sexton as defendants.
Jury selection is scheduled for Thursday, with testimony to open Nov. 9.
Penelec spokesman Scott Surgeoner made a brief statement.
“We believe the judge’s ruling was correct and was based on the facts presented,” Surgeoner said.
The lawsuit was filed by the families of three of the four people who died in the fire – Dolores “Dee” Holland, 50; her grandson, Jordan M. English, 3; and Lindsey Depto, 14, – and also by the father of a girl, Chelsey Hammond, then 14, who was able to escape the fire. Hammond was a daughter of Mrs. Holland. The woman was engaged to Sexton.
Depto and another girl, Alisha McConnell, 15, who also died in the fire, were visiting for a sleepover. No lawsuit was filed by McConnell’s family.
Krumenacker and Tulowitzki, in the 18-page opinion, appeared to invite an appeal so that an appellate court could look at what they termed “a controlling question of law.”
They said, “At issue is whether or not Penelec’s negligence, if any, was a substantial factor in bringing about (the victims’) injuries to satisfy the (legal) element of causation. ... It was this candle that was the actual cause of the fire, and it was Sexton’s, not Penelec’s conduct that placed it in a manner that allowed the fire to occur.”
They concluded, “Penelec’s termination of the electrical service was, in and of itself, harmless.”
In addition, the two judges said, “While it is foreseeable that persons without electrical service may turn to candles to provide illumination, it is not foreseeable that they will leave those candles unattended.”
The danger of unattended, burning candles is well known to the public through not only news reports but consumer warnings and even common sense, Krumenacker and Tulowitzki said.
It also was noted by the judges that there had been sufficient time – after the termination of service and before the fire – for the residents to find safer sources of night illumination, including flashlights.
In dismissing Outsourcing as a defendant, the judges said that any actions of the company “were too remote both in time and the causal chain to be the proximate cause of the fire.”
Local News
Penelec lawsuit over fire deaths dismissed
- Local News
-
-
Lumber building razed
Investigators are searching for the cause of a three-alarm fire that destroyed a former lumber company building Wednesday in Reade Township.
-
Fallen Marine’s body returned
Clinging to one another for emotional support in gusty afternoon winds, seven family members stood on the airport tarmac as Marine Lance Cpl. Joshua T. Twigg was taken off a charter jet.
-
Text message is hate crime, parent says
Bridgett Bailey-Fletcher moved to Westmont last year so her four children could grow up in a safe environment where they would receive a quality education.
But an incident of racial intimidation has caused her to doubt her decision. -
County: Try juvenile as adult in car thefts
Cambria County prosecutors are seeking to have a 17-year-old involved in a crime spree of stealing vehicles stand trial as an adult.
-
Climbing out of the ditch
Calling small-business job creation “the real engine of our economy,” U.S. Sen. Bob Casey urged local economic leaders to support the Small Business Jobs and Credit Act during a stop in Richland on Wednesday.
-
Wreck victim was Johnstown resident
Police in Conemaugh Township, Somerset County, have identified the man killed Tuesday in a motorcycle accident as Edward E. Helsel III, 38, of Carroll Drive, Johnstown.
-
Man pleads to conspiracy in beatings at area motel
One of the six co-defendants in the brutal beating and robbery of two Ohio construction workers at a Richland Township motel has pleaded guilty in county court to two felony criminal conspiracy charges – robbery and aggravated assault.
-
Crime Roundup: Police: Driver deliberately struck another man with car
Troopers said a motorist intentionally drove over a man’s foot, swung the car around and again struck the same person.
-
Jury hears case of disabled trucker
A Johnstown-area trucker who said injuries suffered in a 2008 wreck ruined his career has begun to tell a federal jury why he deserves $75,000-plus in damages.
-
Research institute seeks entries for essay contest
With Breast Cancer Awareness Month on the horizon, Windber Research Institute is holding an essay contest for kids 14 and younger.
- More Local News Headlines
-
