The Tribune Democrat, Johnstown, PA

Local News

December 15, 2009

Judge postpones contempt hearing for Amish couples

EBENSBURG — The long-simmering dispute between an ultraconservative Amish sect and sewage enforcement agencies is back in Cambria County court even as a new attorney for the Amish is trying to find a way to resolve the issues.

Currently at issue is whether two couples from the Swartzentruber sect should be held in contempt of court

– and possibly jailed as punishment

– for moving back into their homes, which had been padlocked by sheriff’s deputies in May on orders from Judge Norman Krumenacker.

The judge was to have held a hearing Tuesday morning on whether Joely and Mary Swartzentruber of Barr Township and John and Susan Miller of Blacklick Township should be held in contempt. They and other members of the sect, which shuns modern conveniences, refuse to meet sewage disposal requirements for their outhouses, although they did make some improvements.

County sewage enforcement officials determined that the padlocks on the two houses were removed and the premises were occupied on Nov. 19.

The couples subsequently moved out again – reportedly after receiving notices of the hearing – and the houses were again locked.

Krumenacker on Tuesday agreed to continue the hearing until an unspecified date at the request of Altoona attorney Thomas Dickey, who has been retained by the National Committee for Amish Religious Freedom to represent the sect members.

The committee, according to its Web site, was founded in 1967 at the University of Chicago to preserve the religious liberty of the Old Order Amish and related groups.

It’s made up of non-Amish members, including lawyers, clergymen and others of many religious faiths, the Web site says.

The Swartzentruber sect, whose members began moving into Cambria County more than a decade ago, first caught the attention of sewage enforcement officials two years ago when complaints were received about two outhouses at the sect’s schoolhouse in Barr Township. Andy Swartzentruber went to jail for 90 days rather than pay fines after being convicted on minor charges of failing to meet sewage disposal regulations.

The school was padlocked in March, and about 20 Amish children have not received any education since then.

Dickey said that he plans to meet with elders of the sect, including the bishop, after Christmas to try to find a way to settle the issues.

“I welcome the opportunity to try to be a go-between the state and its regulations and these people who want to exercise their religious freedom,” Dickey said.

Krumenacker has been unsuccessful in past attempts to reach a compromise.

Attorney William Barbin, who represents both the county sewage enforcement agency and the county building code enforcement agency, did not object to postponing the hearing.

“It’s certainly better to try to resolve the issues rather than being as harsh as possible,” Barbin said.

When Dickey asked the judge about opening the school for classes, Krumenacker said that could be done only if the sect obtains a state Department of Environmental Protection permit and then follows regulations that would enable them to dump the treated waste on their fields.

The regulations include keeping records of the treatments and testing acid levels of the soil, Barbin said.

Text Only | Photo Reprints
Judge postpones contempt hearing for Amish couples
by By SANDRA K. REABUCK , , Tue Dec 15, 2009, 11:25 PM EST
Local News
  • Northeast braces for Earl's arrival

    A tropical storm warning has been issued for New York’s Long Island coast as Hurricane Earl barrels toward the Eastern Seaboard.

    September 2, 2010

  • NEW – Police dog bites girl, mom

    Police say a western Pennsylvania K-9 was likely being protective when he bit a 6-year-old girl and her mother after his handler offered them a ride to school.

    September 2, 2010

  • Bleier: Flight 93 fundraising dinner set for November

    Former running back Rocky Bleier and other ex-Pittsburgh Steelers are organizing a fundraising dinner to benefit the Flight 93 National Memorial.

    September 2, 2010

  • Handyman gets prison

    A former part-time handyman/caregiver for an elderly West Hills woman was sentenced Wednesday to six to 15 years in state prison for misappropriating more than $600,000 from the woman, who thought of him as a son.

    September 1, 2010

  • Barrel contains murder victim

    An investigation into a series of thefts has led state police to discover a barrel containing the remains of a homicide victim in a body of water in Indiana County.

    September 1, 2010

  • Judge overturns ruling on police benefits

    Cambria County Judge Patrick Kiniry says an arbitrator went too far in cutting police officers’ retirement medical benefits in the financially distressed city of Johnstown.

    September 1, 2010

  • Robert Lee Tubbs 02 Rape suspect seeks release on lower bond

    A Portage man arrested over the weekend after a standoff with police wants his $250,000 bond reduced so he can get out of prison.

    September 1, 2010 1 Photo

  • Valu King Store Opens 02 Valu King pushes bargains at 1st Pa. store in chain

    There’s a standard deli, meat cooler and frozen-food section.
    But, near the front of the new Valu King store in Johnstown’s Westwood Plaza, there also are fortress-like stacks of Niagara bottled water and DelGrosso pasta sauce.

    September 1, 2010 1 Photo

  • Dana Conzo 02 Ex-worker charged in CoGo’s robbery

    A Twin Rocks woman has been charged with robbing a CoGo’s convenience store where she once worked.

    September 1, 2010 1 Photo

  • Research institute seeks entries for essay contest

    With Breast Cancer Awareness Month on the horizon, Windber Research Institute is holding an essay contest for kids 14 and younger.

    August 20, 2010

Poll

Which of the region’s big Labor Day weekend events are you planning to attend?

Cambria City Ethnic Festival in Johnstown.
Log House Arts Festival in Westmont.
Bill Dively Memorial Labor Day Bluegrass Festival in Berlin.
Cambria County Fair in Ebensburg.
Fall Harvest Gospel Music Festival in Hooversville.
Forest Hills Labor Day Festival in St. Michael.
Cruisin' the Flood City car show in Johnstown.
All of them.
As many as I can.
None of them.
     View Results
AP Video
Community Calendar
Loading…
Events by eviesays.com
House Ads
Hyperlocal Search
Premier Guide
Find a business

Walking Fingers
Maps, Menus, Store hours, Coupons, and more...
Premier Guide
Popular Searches
Powered by Local.com